WatchTower

Video analysis

The FED has a BIG Problem!!!

Fed faces hawkish inflation versus dovish labor market dilemma.

James LNE 3 min read

James LNE analyzes the Federal Reserve's interest rate decision and the critical disconnect between market expectations and Fed guidance. He examines how Chair Warsh's tone will determine whether the dollar rallies on hawkish reaffirmation of future hikes or sells off on dovish repricing, with implications across USD pairs, precious metals, and equities.

The Fed's Impossible Balancing Act: Inflation vs. Employment

The Federal Reserve faces a critical crossroads heading into its latest interest rate decision. While markets have priced in a hold at 4% today, the real story lies in forward guidance and Chair Warsh's tone regarding future rate hikes. The disconnect between market expectations and Fed projections has created significant trading opportunities across dollar-denominated assets, precious metals, and major currency pairs.

The core problem is straightforward: inflation remains stubbornly elevated while labor market data has deteriorated. Consumer Price Index readings came in at 3.7% versus 3.6% expected, with Producer Price Index at 6.3% year-over-year—both well above the Fed's 2% target. Core PCE sits at 3.4%, and energy-driven inflation continues to pressure headline figures as oil prices move higher. This hawkish backdrop would normally justify aggressive rate hikes.

However, recent employment data tells a different story. Nonfarm Payrolls missed dramatically at 29,000 versus 90,000 expected, while the unemployment rate ticked up to 4.2% from 4.1%. The JOLTS job openings index also declined, signaling potential labor market weakness. This creates a genuine policy dilemma: the Fed typically hikes to combat inflation but cuts to support employment.

Market Pricing vs. Fed Expectations: A 66 Basis Point Gap

The market has priced a terminal rate of 4.66% by June 2027, implying multiple rate hikes through late 2026 and into 2027. The Fed's own median projection, however, sits at 4.25%—a 66 basis point gap. Banks including BNP Paribas, HSBC, and Crédit Agricole expect December hikes and continued tightening into 2027, yet the Fed's dot plot suggests rate cuts beginning in 2028.

This disagreement matters enormously for the dollar. If Warsh reaffirms the hawkish hiking cycle markets expect, the dollar should rally and yields should rise, pressuring gold and other dollar-inverse assets. Conversely, if the Fed signals caution due to labor market concerns, a sharp repricing lower could trigger dollar weakness and precious metals strength.

Trading the Fed Decision: Key Setups

James LNE identifies several high-probability trade setups contingent on Fed messaging:

  • Gold and Silver: Both have held key support at 4000 and previous lows respectively. A hawkish Fed could trigger break-and-retest patterns targeting 3500–3400 in gold, with entries on rejection of retests into Fibonacci zones.
  • USD/CAD: Displays textbook bullish technicals with daily uptrend, 200-moving average support, and Fibonacci alignment with prior structure. However, the Bank of Canada decision (50/50 hold/hike) adds complexity; optimal entry timing awaits clarity on both central banks.
  • EUR/USD: An existing 4R winner since September 8th continues lower on the daily. H4 timeframe offers fresh break-and-retest opportunities into new lows, with continuation potential if the Fed confirms hawkish bias.
  • GBP/USD: Presents a two-catalyst setup. If the UK budget supports sterling and the Fed disappoints dovishly, longs could work. If the budget pressures the pound and the Fed stays hawkish, shorts become attractive.

The analyst's lean is toward a cautiously hawkish hold—maintaining forward guidance for future hikes despite labor weakness, justified by persistent inflation and rising oil prices. This stance would support the dollar and provide the catalyst for the outlined short positions in precious metals and EUR/USD.

Critically, James emphasizes trading the context of Fed guidance rather than the news event itself, allowing new information to refine his broader dollar thesis before executing trades.

The data in this video, live

The figures in the video were read off the terminal on 28 October 2026. These pages show the same data as it stands today, free.

Transcript

2,808 words, with timestamps

0:00The Fed vs the market

Markets price a hiking cycle out to 4.66%, 66 basis points above where the Fed is today. There is a disagreement the market seems to be pricing in more than what the Fed is expecting to do. However, as we've just discussed, the problem comes if Warsh doesn't reaffirm those hikes. We could see that repricing come into play with the dollar and a larger move to the downside as a lot of those expectations are taken away.

0:24Today's decision: a hold on the surface

0:25Ladies and gentlemen, we have the Federal Reserve interest rate decision coming out later today, 6pm UK time. I am recording this a day ahead so it does say due in one day. However, the video will come out Wednesday morning. So as we can see, the current Federal Reserve interest rate is 4% and the forecast is also 4%. So on the surface, this just looks like we are going to have a hold. With very little of interest going to happen. However, it could get more interesting than that. And whatever comes out from the Fed will be a big driver of the US dollar and US dollar related markets.

0:57What the banks expect

So on our data forecasts, we can see what the institutions are expecting. Now you may notice that every single one that has a reading for this meeting is expecting a hold. You can see 4%, 4%, 4%, and they are all... Again, institutions, banks. However, moving forwards into December, what is quite interesting, this is what really will be key, is the forward expectations of the markets and institutions. So we can see December, almost all of them, in fact, every single one of them, are expecting hikes. So we can see Crédit Agricole, Danske Bank, HSBC, so on and so on. Now of course they don't all have what they're expecting just yet, because obviously that's still two months away, so it's a while away. So they may not publish their data just yet, but again, so far, this is seeming like the banks are still expecting the Fed to remain hawkish.

1:44Then we go to January 2027 and BNP is expecting the Fed to go up to 4.5% which would be two consecutive hikes. So the Fed does have a relatively high bar to meet here for the markets to remain satisfied or in other words for the dollar to stay supported. So we're actually able to see how repricing is going within these major central banks. So we have a widget called rates across banks and we can see that the ECB is actually repriced the most by losing 35 basis points.

2:13And actually central banks across the board have all been getting repriced in a more dovish way, So what is interesting here is the Federal Reserve, that has moved or been repriced by 17 basis points.

2:24What's priced

2:23And when we look on our central bank widget here, we can see the implied rate, which is this green line, has been coming down. And there is a terminal rate expected by the futures market at 4.66%, and this would be roughly around June 2027. And down here we can see what the expectations are of the markets moving forwards. So in the meeting today we have an 88% probability of a hold, however going forwards through December into later 2027, we are seeing these hikes that have been priced in by the markets.

2:55So we're going to discuss how this can actually impact the markets and also what trades we can look at very shortly. So if we scroll down on the other central bank widget which is set to the rate and stance, we can actually see the breakdown here. So we can see tomorrow's hold into the 25 basis point December hike. Now this says the Fed sits at 4% after a 25 basis point hike 41 days ago and will almost certainly hold tomorrow 88% priced.

3:20UniCredit and Westpac flag Chair Warsh's tone as decisive. A hawkish reaffirmation would send yields higher and support the dollar. While a more cautious message could ease pressure, markets price a hiking cycle out to 4.66%, 66 basis points above where the Fed is today, with resilient growth, Q3 GDP at 3%, core PCE also at 3%, leaving little room for a dovish surprise.

3:47The Fed vs the market

Now to dig a little bit deeper here, we can actually change the setting of this widget and put it onto latest decision. And what we can see here is very interesting. So the committee median is at 4.25%, so this is the Fed members' expectation. The markets have gone up to 4.75% here. So there is a disagreement in the market, seems to be pricing in more than what the Fed is expecting to do. And then we can go on the projections tab up here, and we can see the federal funds rate into 2027 is actually expected to be at 4.1%.

4:18Then 2028 and 2029, we're actually expecting to see rate cuts. And we can see this reflected on the dot plot as well down here. So we can see that the Fed is expecting to hike rates. However, not nearly as much as what the markets are

4:32Inflation vs jobs

4:31expecting. And then we can go over to the US fundamentals, so we already know that the Fed's main focus was inflation not too long ago. And since then inflation has continued to move to the upside. So we can see CPI at 3.7% whereas the expected print was 3.6% so that is heating up. We see core inflation year on year at 2.6%, PCE at 3.4%, which actually was a tick to the downside. However, PPI year on year at 6.3%. So we can see that inflation across the board, so we can see inflation generally speaking, is heating up and is way above that Fed 2% target. So this on face value could be used as quite a hawkish signal on its own.

The Fed has previously said that energy driven inflation is a concern. And again inflation has been their main focus. However the problem is the labour market data that we've been getting. So we can see JOLTS had a move to the downside, NFP had a large miss to 29k from the expected 90k.

5:27And unemployment rate went up to 4.2% from the expected 4.1%. Now what do we typically expect here? Well as we just said, the Fed can hike rates to deal with high inflation. However, we also expect the Fed to cut rates to deal with a weakening labour market, so this might be a reason for the Fed to not reaffirm hikes as aggressively as what the markets may be expecting and wanting to hear.

5:50The dollar

Now the DXY is displaying very nice price action here. We've got very clear higher lows getting formed as well as higher highs. So the market structure itself is looking very promising. And the recent pullback we've had to me just looks like a break and retest off the prior resistance that we've got on the left side. And as you can see, since we had that retest, we have seen buyers stepping in ahead of the Fed. So this could be another sign that the markets are expecting some sort of hawkish hike from Warsh. However, as we've just discussed, the problem comes if Warsh doesn't reaffirm those hikes.

So the markets have been pricing in these hikes for the Fed. As we've seen into 2027, and if Warsh gives the market reasons to reprice that and potentially expect further holds or maybe even sooner cuts. We could see that repricing come into play with the dollar and a larger move to the downside as a lot of those expectations are taken away. However, the

6:42My lean

6:43way I'm actually leaning is a cautiously hawkish hold. And the reason I'm saying that is kind of a mixture of everything. So yes, we have had weaker labour data and I do think that that will put a little bit of a dampener on what the Fed can do. and how aggressive they can be with hikes. As I've already said, we do know inflation was the main focus, inflation has heated up, and it's still above that 2% target. But then we also look at oil prices. So again, the nuance here isn't just inflation, but it's energy driven inflation.

7:11So when oil prices are continuing to move up, we can typically expect inflation to follow in line and continue to heat up as well, and that's due to people's energy costs being higher. So in this situation I don't think the Fed has much room to be neutral or even slightly dovish. I think they may be forced to maintain a cautiously hawkish tone, given the oil prices are moving higher and inflation is likely to follow in the footsteps.

7:37And if we zoom out on the DXY here, you can see that the weekly idea that I've been talking about quite often on this channel is still alive, where we come down to this trend line that's been established since roughly 2008, we have these bullish cycles every time. And now we came down again in sort of mid 2025. And yes, we had a bit of consolidation. However, we have had that break above. And we do now have reasons for the dollar to be bullish on the back of the potentially more hawkish Fed.

8:05Trades I'm watching

So with all of that said, there are a few markets I'm paying attention to here, which are USD/CAD, gold, silver and EUR/USD. So we can see gold has been holding this 4000 level very well and this is the previous level on the left. And we saw previously when we came down to 4000 we did see buyers stepping in very heavily. So the fact that we have come down to 4000, we've seen buyers stepping in yet again and we have the Fed coming out very soon.

8:30I'm not looking to do anything here on gold just yet. I would much rather wait to see what is said in the press conference and the statements so then I can start building a thesis on what I'm expecting going forwards. Now as I said, I would expect the Fed to at least maintain some sort of cautiously hawkish tone. Which given the fact that oil is moving higher and yields are still elevated could be enough for gold to break out of 4,000 and potentially start trending towards 3500.

8:58maybe even 3400. So I wouldn't mind looking for some sort of break and retest. So down here on the H4, if we take the previous swing high to the low that we've just formed, maybe some sort of break and retest could be quite appealing here. So as you can see, we have broken out of this range that we had. We've broken the previous lows. We draw the Fib from the high to the low, and our Fib zone at roughly this 50% does line up with those lows.

9:23So it could be a case of looking for the break, the retest, waiting for a rejection of the retest and then entering short looking for that continuation. So the trade could look something very similar to this. Now again, I want to highlight the fact that I'm not going to do this just if gold does come higher. This will be a case of I need to use the Fed as a catalyst to get into this trade. So the Fed would need to be hawkish and reaffirm those hikes for the dollar to catch a bid and bring gold lower.

9:49Now the same idea applies here on silver, we would take the previous high to the low, and we can see that the Fib zone lines up really nicely with the previous low on the left. So it would be exactly the same. We've had the break, looking for the retest into this level, the rejection and a continuation lower. Now USD/CAD is looking really nice for a technical entry here. We've got the daily bullish trend, we've got the Fib from the low to the high.

10:11We can see prices come in, use the 200 moving average as a dynamic support, rejecting our Fib zone, which also lines up with previous structure on the left for again that sort of break and retest idea. So purely from a technical view, this looks like a fantastic textbook long position. However, we don't just have the Fed tomorrow, we also have the Bank of Canada that's coming out. And the Bank of Canada seems pretty much like a 50/50 coin flip between a hold and a hike.

10:38So this is yet again another position I will not be taking until either after the Fed or potentially even Thursday morning once I have a very clear view. And a better understanding of what I can expect going forwards from the US dollar and in this case, the Canadian dollar too. And back to EUR/USD. This is a trade I've been talking about for a long time, and I've been sat in it since the 8th of September, so it's coming up on two months now. And you can see this is now coming up on roughly a 4R trade, which is absolutely beautiful. But you may notice down here, I'm looking at another trade. So I can't do anything on this daily timeframe because the pullbacks are just either non-existent or extremely small.

11:16So I've got to go down to the H4 timeframe, and right here you can see I've got the Fib drawn from this high, and I'm just waiting for a low to get printed. Ideally, the low will close below the previous low on the left, creating a new lower low. Then I can look for the retest into the low of the range, the rejection and again that continuation to the downside. GBP/USD could also be a fantastic trade tomorrow, we do also have the UK budget, not just the Fed.

11:41Now I did discuss the UK budget in yesterday's video, so feel free to go and check that out. However, if the UK budget is negative for the pound and investors become concerned around potential growth around tax increases, and the Fed is hawkish, a short position on GBP/USD could be extremely favourable. But then we could also look for the opposite, if the UK budget is supportive of the pound. And the Fed is dovish, a long position on GBP/USD could be

12:07The scanners

12:06very warranted. Now over here on EdgeFinder we are seeing EUR/USD getting this bearish reading. However, we're also seeing USD/CAD getting a bearish reading. So at the moment USD/CAD does not favour that long idea I was looking at, however EUR/USD definitely does. We can also see the GBP/USD is also getting a bullish reading here, so that would align if we do get that budget that is supportive of the sterling. And some sort of dovish repricing within the US dollar after the Fed. And on the trade scanner here on the WatchTower we can see that we do have the NASDAQ and the Dow getting bullish readings along with the S&P so if we get that dovish Fed, it could be very beneficial for these markets and these could become a lot more interesting of readings. GBP/USD is also getting a bullish reading on the WatchTower just like it is on EdgeFinder.

12:52And we can see EUR/USD, gold and silver are getting bearish readings. So it will be very interesting to see what happens tomorrow.

12:59How I'll trade it

13:00However, to make it very clear, I'm not trading directly into the news. I don't trade news itself. I always trade the context of what that news is, so whatever the Fed does come out with in terms of forward guidance will go into my US dollar thesis. And hopefully that will give me some more ammunition to start firing into the markets based on a new educated decision. If you've enjoyed this video, please make sure you've liked and subscribed so you can continue to see more of my content on an almost daily basis.

13:26And if you would like access to the WatchTower or a discount on EdgeFinder, click the links in the description. There is also a link there for you to join my free Discord if that's something you would want to do. Thank you for watching, stay safe, don't get margin called and I'll see you in the next video.

The transcript of the video as published, lightly cleaned. It is spoken analysis from 28 October 2026, not financial advice. CFDs are high risk and most retail accounts lose money.

Every number in this video came off the board.

Composite scores on 24 markets and the Analyst videos panel, with positioning across 44 and the research behind them. The terminal is $10 for your first month, then $49 a month. Cancel from Billing at any time.