Video analysis
Gold Bulls Could Be TRAPPED
Gold bulls may be trapped as real yields and hawkish Fed expectations surge.
James LNE examines why recent gold and silver declines may signal deeper weakness ahead rather than buying opportunities. He analyzes conflicting signals from multiple analytical frameworks—bearish Watchtower readings versus bullish Edge Finder scores—and identifies key technical and fundamental headwinds, including rising real yields, crowded retail long positioning, and unfavorable near-term seasonality.
The Real Yields Trap: Why Gold's Rally May Be Illusory
Gold and silver have experienced sharp declines—down 7% and 9% respectively—prompting retail traders to ask whether these represent attractive dips or early warnings of deeper weakness. The answer lies not in price action alone, but in the shifting opportunity cost of holding non-yielding assets in a higher-rate environment.
The fundamental driver is straightforward: as the Federal Reserve signals increased probability of rate hikes, real yields have risen sharply. The two-year US Treasury yield now offers 4.36%, while the ten-year sits at elevated levels. For investors, this creates a compelling alternative to gold. Why hold an asset that generates zero yield when government debt pays 4–5% annually? This mechanical headwind explains why institutional positioning has shifted decisively toward the dollar, despite broader economic weakness in growth and labor markets.
Conflicting Signals and the Crowded Long Trap
Multiple analytical frameworks are sending contradictory messages. The Edge Finder platform rates gold as bullish with a score of 7, while the Watchtower—which incorporates central bank bias, COT flows, seasonality, and retail positioning—marks it as bearish. This divergence is crucial. The Watchtower's bearish reading reflects a structural problem: 81% of retail traders are long gold, creating a crowded positioning trap. Historically, when retail traders reach such extreme long concentrations, reversals tend to be sharp and unforgiving.
Seasonality compounds the risk. From mid-September through early October, both gold and silver face headwinds based on 15-year historical patterns. While the five-year seasonality for gold shows some bullish bias later in the year, the near-term seasonal window is decidedly bearish.
The Technical Setup and Path Lower
Gold is currently testing its 200-day moving average after a recent golden cross—a bullish signal that may prove to be a trap before further downside. The critical technical level is 4,000, which previously acted as strong support. If this level breaks, the next significant support zone sits at 3,500, where previous highs from earlier price action provide a natural target.
A potential short setup would require two conditions: the Edge Finder must lose its bullish reading on gold, while the Watchtower maintains its bearish stance. From there, traders could look for a retracement into Fibonacci levels and previous support zones, followed by a continuation lower toward 3,500.
Bank forecasts offer some longer-term optimism—Crédit Agricole targets 5,500 by end-2027—but near-term expectations are lackluster, with most banks forecasting only modest gains through year-end 2026. The disconnect between long-term bullishness and short-term caution reflects the reality that gold faces a cyclical headwind from rising real yields that may persist for several more quarters.
The data in this video, live
The figures in the video were read off the terminal on 1 September 2026. These pages show the same data as it stands today, free.
Transcript
2,084 words
Silver has fallen over nine percent and gold has fallen almost seven percent. So are these good buying the dip opportunities or is it actually time to start selling these markets? While the US dollar is exhibiting strength off the back of the Jackson Hole into this week, however, the dollar is currently retesting its major level of previous support as now resistance. And we do see yesterday's daily candle close strongly bearish. Now something quite interesting is the trade scanner on the WatchTower. Silver is getting a score of forty which is a bearish reading. Gold is forty two which is also bearish.
The Nasdaq is forty three whereas dollar yen is getting a reading of fifty seven. So there is a very light theme here of buying the dollar. So on the rate expectations widget on the WatchTower, the Federal Reserve is now at a sixty two percent probability of a hike. So the grey dashed line and the dotted line are previous rate expectations, whereas the green line is the current rate path. So as we can see, the green line is coming above both of the grey lines, meaning the markets are expecting future hikes at an increased probability. And for the next meeting on the sixteenth of September, one week ago, we had a forty percent probability of a hike.
Yesterday it was fifty eight percent. It's now today, currently set at sixty two percent probability of a hike. And then on the eighth of June in twenty twenty seven, the current probability is ninety six point one percent. So the increasing probability of a rate hike is what is currently bolstering the dollar off washes. Relatively hawkish Jackson Hole Symposium. Now don't forget, during this period on the left, the markets were pricing out rate hikes. And we can see why. Very clearly on the edge finder with the US dollars thirty percent score, we've had weak growth services. PMI is disappointed from its forecast and the labor market is extremely weak with NFP massively undershooting its forecast.
However, what we do see is inflation remains elevated, although we have seen a little bit of a cool off in inflation, such as PPI coming down from four point nine to four point seven. Inflation remains above the Federal Reserve's target at two percent, and the edge finder reflects that really nicely. Here we can see the target inflation rate is at two percent, whereas CPI is currently at three point four percent. And again PPI here at four point seven percent with an inflation target at two percent and PCE sitting at three point three percent, again with that two percent inflation target. And what you may notice with all of these charts is we're not seeing a massive quick cooldown in inflation.
Yes, we had some cooler prints, but then nothing spectacular. So something interesting on the edge finder is a lot of the dollar scores have actually been depleted. So on euro dollar scorecard we can see the score over time historically was very bullish not too long ago and is very quickly been dropping in score now sitting at two which is neutral. And we can see the same thing here on GBP. USD with this consistent degradation in the score. Now it does seem silver is holding its ground. It is still getting this very bullish reading of positive eight. Gold is also holding up with a very bullish score of seven.
However, as I mentioned, the WatchTower is giving gold and silver a bearish score. So we're getting two different signals from two different platforms. So the reason silver is getting this bearish score is because of the central bank reading. So as we mentioned, the rate hike probabilities by the fed has been increasing. And the WatchTower picks up on this and counts it into its score as well as the forward guidance. So this is strongly leaning in the US dollars favor. We can see c o t level is also bearish, meaning that leveraged funds is more long on the dollar as opposed to silver. We can see seasonality is actually very bearish here as well as the retail positioning which is bearish.
So on the final view what we can see is real yields are the dominant headwind. Domestic market. Central banks are leaning hawkish five out of twenty score which mechanically raises the opportunity cost of holding a Non-yielding silver. While the two and ten year yield spread sits flat at zero point four four percent, consistent with late cycle dynamics that historically compress precious metal demand. So this really isn't much of a fundamental reading. If anything, the fundamentals are actually kind of flat. Here on the WatchTower. We're seeing more of a nuanced and contextual bearish reading.
So what we can do on the WTA advanced chart, we can click on layers and then we can click on score pane. And this draws the score on the chart. So we can see exactly what's been going on. So as this market has been increasing in value we can see the score has been decreasing. So we've had a very clear divergence from what we're seeing now on silver is this ten percent move to the downside and possibly even further. So the retail book is currently getting a crowded long reading, with eighty seven percent of retail traders currently in long positions on silver on the retail positioning chart history.
What we can see is a massive jump from the sixth of August to the eighth of August in long positions. And as I mentioned, seasonality is very bearish for silver as well. So what we can see from September the thirteenth into around October, the first on the fifteen and ten year history, which is the green in the orange line, silver is very bearish. However, on the five year seasonality line, it is actually quite bullish basically from now into the end of the year. And that brings us on to gold, which is basically seeing the same reading. So we've got the central banks way. We're seeing c o t flow, which is basically the week on week change seasonality and the retail positioning.
And then the final view is essentially the same as silver. So what we can see on the CO2 week on week change here is yes, gold had more contracts added. However, the percentage is what is driving it. So whilst gold had three thousand contracts added and the US dollar only had one thousand in terms of relative quantity. This was only a two percent addition for gold, whereas for the US dollar it was a thirteen percent addition. And again with gold, we do see retail traders eighty one percent long with this crowded long reading. Gold seasonality is very similar to silver. However, in this case, the five year seasonality line also lines up.
So roughly from mid-September into around the first of October, we can yet again expect this bearish price action. Now it's not all doom and gloom for gold. So what we can do is go into bank forecasts for gold. And we can click all of these so we can see where the banks are actually expecting gold to be. So by the end of twenty twenty seven, Crédit Agricole is forecasting gold to be at five thousand five hundred by the fourth quarter of twenty twenty six. Basically, by the end of this year, Crédit Agricole expects gold to be at five thousand. UniCredit expects gold to be at four thousand eight hundred by the end of this year, and then Ocbc is expecting gold to be at four thousand six hundred by the end of this year.
So as you can see long term, it does seem they are bullish. However, shorter term for this year the optimism is actually quite lackluster. Something quite interesting on the bank research tab on currency research for gold and the US dollar, we actually see these conflicting. So the US dollar is getting a net bearish reading, whereas gold is getting a net bullish reading. And this is over thirty days worth of bank reports. So whilst I'm not yet looking for short positions on gold or silver, I do think the opportunity might be arising. Now for transparency. I am still long on gold. I have these three positions here that are long term DCA approaches.
These are very, very small size. So the idea with these ones is to leave them active and keep buying gold at low prices. However, this position, the fourth one is actually more of a short term speculative long position. So what I did here was draw the fib from the low to the high. And I tried to enter or did enter on this sixty one point eight percent retracement and the retest of the previous highs on the left into this bullish trend and the bullish edge finder reading. But what we can see is gold is continuing to move to the downside, currently testing its two hundred day moving average. Something else to note is we've actually had another golden cross on gold.
So we had the death Cross or the Golden Cross. The downside meaning we changed from bullish trend into the bearish trend here. And we very quickly changed back into a bullish trend. However, this could potentially just be a trap before we continue lower and break this four thousand level. That acted as a really strong level of support previously. So for me to actually get into a short position on gold, I need a few requirements to get met. I first of all need the edge finder to lose its bullish reading on gold. I need the WatchTower to maintain its bearish reading. Then I will draw the fib from the high to wherever the low may be printed, which could be around this four thousand level of support.
So we could come back down, retest this level, have some sort of retracement into the fib, into the moving averages, into the previous support that we formed not too long ago. And then look for a continuation lower into possibly three thousand five hundred. Now the reason I'm looking towards three thousand five hundred is because if four thousand breaks here, the next real line in the sand or the next real significant support on a price action basis is the three thousand five hundred level where we've got these previous highs on the left. So we could be looking for a trade very similar to this, where we actually end up with a really clean retest of the previous structure we just spoke about at the fib zone break below four thousand retest of this level for a potential scale in.
And then we write it down towards three thousand five hundred. So here I have the gold daily chart. And what we're going to do is just add some yields. So we're going to add the ten year yield to a new price scale. And we're going to add the US two year yield to a new price scale. So what we can see here is a relatively inverse correlation. So at the moment what we are seeing is yields moving to the upside and gold moving to the downside. But why is this. Well the way we need to look at this is called opportunity cost. So if a US two year yield is going to pay four point three six two percent for you to essentially loan the government debt, this is a pretty good ROI.
Whereas with gold we don't get a yield. There is no return for just holding it. And with the situation in the Middle East and rate hikes, being priced in, gold is no longer looking attractive compared to holding yields where you are getting paid anywhere between four to five percent. So let me know in the comments. Are you looking to be a seller of gold, or are you looking to be a buyer of the dips? Now remember you can get a license for the WatchTower one hundred percent free with the first link in the description, and you can get a discount on the edge finder with the code in the description. Thank you very much for watching. Stay safe and don't get margin called.
The transcript of the video as published, lightly cleaned. It is spoken analysis from 1 September 2026, not financial advice. CFDs are high risk and most retail accounts lose money.
Every number in this video came off the board.
Composite scores on 24 markets and the Analyst videos panel, with positioning across 44 and the research behind them. The terminal is $10 for your first month, then $49 a month. Cancel from Billing at any time.


